Quick Answer
No. In Canada, publishing a client testimonial without permission is reviewable conduct under section 74.02 of the Competition Act, unless the person who gave it had already published it themselves, or you obtained their written approval before publishing. Privacy law adds a second layer the moment you attach a name, a job title or a photograph. Here is what a compliant testimonial, case study and client logo wall actually requires.
Written by Cody Wise, founder of Wise Media, Calgary. This article summarises Canadian advertising and privacy rules as published by the Competition Bureau, the Department of Justice and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. It is general information for operators, not legal advice. Confirm your own position with a Canadian lawyer before publishing anything you are unsure about.
Summary
- Written permission is the statutory default. Section 74.02 of the Competition Act makes publishing a testimonial reviewable conduct unless it was previously published by the person who gave it, or was approved in writing before you published it.
- What you publish has to match what they approved. The section carries an accordance requirement, so trimming a quote until it says something stronger is its own problem.
- A testimonial that states a result is also a performance claim. The Competition Bureau says plainly that testimonials usually do not amount to adequate proof.
- Nobody has to be fooled. Under subsection 52(1.1), it is not necessary to prove that any person was actually deceived or misled.
- Privacy is a separate gate. A client’s name and photograph used for marketing sit outside PIPEDA’s business contact information exclusion, which only covers information used solely to communicate with that person about their work.
- The fix is a one page release covering the quote, the attribution, the image, the logo, the channels and the term. It takes ten minutes and it closes every gate at once.

Table of Contents
- Can you publish a client testimonial without permission in Canada?
- What section 74.02 of the Competition Act actually says
- When a testimonial becomes a performance claim
- The privacy layer: names, job titles and photographs
- Client logos, case studies and the confidentiality trap
- How to get a testimonial release that actually holds
- Common mistakes, and what to publish when permission is refused
- Frequently asked questions
Can you publish a client testimonial without permission in Canada?
No, with one narrow exception. Section 74.02 of the Competition Act treats publishing a testimonial as reviewable conduct unless you can establish that the person who gave it had already made or published it themselves, or that they approved it and gave written permission before you published. In both cases, what you put out has to accord with what they said or approved.
That exception is narrower than most agencies assume. A public Google review counts, because the client published it. A line from a private email does not, because nobody published it and nobody approved it in writing. The distinction is not about how enthusiastic the client sounded. It is about whether the words were already public or whether you hold written sign off.
This matters commercially, not just legally. Testimonials and case studies are the highest converting assets most service businesses own, which is why we treat them as a production workflow inside our content production service rather than something you chase after a project wraps. The businesses that collect permission at handover end up with a library. The ones that ask eighteen months later end up with three unusable quotes and a logo wall they cannot defend.
The three gates a published testimonial has to clear
| Gate | What it governs | Source of the rule |
|---|---|---|
| Authorisation | May you publish these words at all | Competition Act s.74.02 |
| Substantiation | Is the claim inside the quote provable | Competition Act s.74.01(1)(b), s.52 |
| Privacy | May you attach a name, title, face or company | PIPEDA and substantially similar provincial laws |
Most businesses think about the first gate and ignore the other two. The expensive failures almost always come from the second.
What section 74.02 of the Competition Act actually says
The marginal note on section 74.02 reads “Representation as to reasonable test and publication of testimonials”. It captures a person who, to promote the supply or use of a product or any business interest, directly or indirectly publishes a testimonial with respect to a product, unless that person can establish one of two alternatives.
- The testimonial “was previously made or published by the person by whom the test was made or the testimonial was given”; or
- It “was, before being made or published, approved and permission to make or publish it was given in writing by the person by whom the test was made or the testimonial was given”.
Either route then carries the same condition: the testimonial you publish has to accord with the one previously made, published or approved. Note the burden. The section is written so that the advertiser establishes the exception, which in practice means the advertiser keeps the paperwork.
Section 74.02 sits in Part VII.1 of the Act, the civil reviewable conduct regime, not the criminal side. That is not a reason to relax. Part VII.1 is where the administrative monetary penalties live, and the Competition Bureau can pursue it without proving criminal intent.
Does an enthusiastic email count as approval?
It depends entirely on what the email says. A client writing “this was the best launch we have ever had” has not approved anything. They have made a private statement. If you then lift that sentence onto a sales page, you have published a testimonial that was neither previously published by them nor approved in writing before publication.
If you reply with the exact wording, the exact page it will appear on and the attribution you intend to use, and they write back agreeing to it, you are in materially different territory. The approval is in writing, it precedes publication, and it is specific enough that what you publish can be shown to accord with it. That is the practical test to apply: could you put the approval and the published asset side by side and show they match.
| Scenario | Clears s.74.02? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quoting a public Google review verbatim, attributed as written | Yes | Previously published by the person who gave it |
| Quoting that review but deleting the qualifying second half | No | Does not accord with what was published |
| Lifting a sentence from a private email | No | Neither previously published nor approved in writing |
| Emailing the exact quote and page, client replies approving it | Yes | Written approval obtained before publication |
| Verbal yes on a call, noted in your CRM | No | Permission was not given in writing |
| Signed release covering quote, name, photo and channels | Yes | Written approval, specific, pre publication |
Public reviews are the cheapest compliant source of social proof you have, which is one more reason to run a deliberate review request system rather than hoping. We cover the platform rules separately in our guide to Google’s review policy in Canada, including why review gating is a policy breach regardless of what Canadian law says.
When a testimonial becomes a performance claim
Permission solves authorisation. It does nothing for substantiation. The moment a quote contains a number or an outcome, it is also a representation about what your service does, and a different part of the Act applies.
The Competition Bureau’s guidance on performance claims states that “Under paragraph 74.01(1)(b) of the Competition Act, you cannot make a claim about a product’s performance, its effectiveness, or its length of life, unless you can prove that the claim is based on an adequate and proper test.” The Bureau is explicit that this covers “words, images and design elements on a website or social media”, not just packaging.
On the same subject, the Bureau’s page on false or misleading representations lists this among its don’ts: “Don’t make a performance claim unless you can prove it, even if you think it is accurate. Testimonials usually do not amount to adequate proof.”
Read that twice. A happy client saying your work tripled their leads is not evidence that your work triples leads. It is one anecdote, uncontrolled, from a party with a relationship to you. The Bureau’s own testing criteria say a test must be conducted before the claim is made, under controlled circumstances, must eliminate subjectivity as far as possible, must reflect real world usage, and must support the general impression the marketing creates. It also warns against basing performance claims on “anecdotal stories”.
The general impression test, and why disclaimers do not save you
Canadian advertising law is not read literally. Subsection 52(4) of the Act requires the general impression conveyed by a representation to be taken into account along with its literal meaning. The Bureau’s guidance on the general impression test says a message can fail even where it is “literally or technically true but creates a false or misleading impression”.
Three consequences for a testimonial wall:
- Selection creates an impression. Six quotes all naming a specific result imply that result is typical. If it is not typical, the page can mislead even though every individual quote is true and approved.
- Fine print rarely fixes it. The Bureau says directly: “Do avoid fine print disclaimers. They often fail to change the general impression conveyed by an advertisement.” A grey “results not typical” line under a wall of numbers is weak protection.
- Your staff count as you. The Bureau notes that “Advertisers may be held responsible for representations made by employees.” A salesperson improvising a client result on a call is the company making the claim.
What the penalties are
These are published maximums in Canadian dollars, not expected outcomes. Verify the current figures against the Bureau before relying on them, because the amounts have moved with recent amendments.
| Route | First occurrence | Subsequent |
|---|---|---|
| Civil AMP, individual | Up to CAD $750,000 | Up to CAD $1,000,000 |
| Civil AMP, corporation | Up to CAD $10,000,000 | Up to CAD $15,000,000 |
| Civil AMP alternative basis | The Bureau’s performance claims page states the penalty may instead be the greater of the amounts above and three times the benefit derived, or, where that benefit cannot be reasonably determined, 3% of annual worldwide gross revenues | |
| Criminal, summary conviction | Fine up to CAD $200,000 and/or imprisonment up to one year | |
| Criminal, on indictment | Fine at the discretion of the court and/or imprisonment up to 14 years | |
The criminal route under section 52 requires a materially false or misleading representation made knowingly or recklessly. The civil route does not. And subsection 52(1.1) states for greater certainty that it is not necessary to prove that any person was deceived or misled. The absence of a complaining customer is not a defence.
One more development worth tracking. Canadian advertising lawyer Steve Szentesi writes that, following the 2024 amendments, private parties can seek leave from the Competition Tribunal to bring civil deceptive marketing proceedings from June 2025, subject to a public interest leave test. We could not confirm that timing against a Bureau page, so treat it as a secondary source and verify before acting on it. If it holds, a competitor, not only the regulator, can put your claims in front of a tribunal.
The privacy layer: names, job titles and photographs
A testimonial that clears the Competition Act can still breach privacy law. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner describes personal information under PIPEDA as including “any factual or subjective information, recorded or not, about an identifiable individual”, with name among the examples.
Businesses often reach for the business contact information exclusion here. Read the condition carefully. The OPC’s summary of PIPEDA requirements says business contact information such as a name, title, business address, telephone number or email is excluded when it is “collected, used or disclosed solely for the purpose of communicating with that person in relation to their employment or profession”.
Publishing someone’s name and headshot on a sales page is not communicating with that person about their job. It is using their identity to market your business. The OPC pages do not address testimonials directly, so this is a reading rather than a stated rule, but the condition in the exclusion is specific and a marketing use does not appear to meet it.
Express consent, new purposes and withdrawal
Three things from the OPC’s consent principle decide how a testimonial release should be written.
- Express is the default. “While consent should generally be express, it can be implied in strictly defined circumstances.” Express consent is generally required where the use falls “outside of the reasonable expectations of the individual”. A client who hired you to build a website did not reasonably expect their face on your homepage.
- Marketing is a new purpose. Personal information may be used only for the purposes identified when it was collected, and fresh consent is needed for a new purpose. Information you gathered to deliver a project was not collected to advertise your firm.
- Consent can be withdrawn. Individuals can withdraw consent at any time, subject to legal or contractual restrictions and reasonable notice, and you must inform them of the implications. Build a removal path before you need one.
Note also that Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec have privacy laws the OPC describes as substantially similar, which generally apply to intra provincial activity in place of PIPEDA. If your client and your business are both in one of those provinces, check that province’s statute rather than assuming the federal rule governs.
Client logos, case studies and the confidentiality trap
The logo wall is the most common unlicensed asset on a Canadian agency website. A client logo is usually a registered or unregistered trademark, and displaying it to promote your own business is a use of that mark. Most clients will not object. Some are contractually unable to allow it, and a few will object loudly.

Read your own contract before you publish the case study
Standard confidentiality clauses in a master services agreement frequently cover the existence of the engagement, not just its contents. If your MSA says neither party will disclose confidential information including the fact of the relationship, your case study breaches it even if every number in it is accurate and approved.
Clients in regulated sectors are the usual sticking point. Law firms, financial advisers, healthcare providers and public sector buyers often operate under rules or procurement terms that restrict being named as a reference. Ask at contract stage, not at launch.
- Add a publicity clause to your own service agreement granting a limited licence to name the client and display their mark for promotional purposes, with an opt out.
- If the client’s paper governs, request the carve out explicitly rather than hoping silence means yes.
- Keep the approved logo file and the approval together, so a future team member cannot pull a mark off the client’s website and use it in the wrong colourway.
Ownership questions cut both ways here. If you designed the mark you are displaying, who owns it is a separate issue worth settling in writing, and we unpack that in who owns your logo copyright in Canada.
Photography adds a third owner
A filmed or photographed testimonial involves the subject’s consent, the client’s brand, and the photographer’s copyright, which does not transfer automatically on commission. We covered the current Canadian position on commissioned photography in professional photos versus stock images. Get the release and the assignment in the same pass.
How to get a testimonial release that actually holds
A compliant release is one page and takes ten minutes to send. Collect it at project handover, when goodwill is highest and the client is still in your calendar.
- Write the quote out in full and paste it into the request. Approval of a specific wording is what the accordance requirement needs. Do not ask them to approve “a testimonial”.
- State the attribution exactly as it will appear. Full name, job title, company name, city. If you later promote them in the quote, that is a change to what was approved.
- Name the channels and the term. Website, proposals, social, paid ads, case study PDF. State whether it runs indefinitely or for a fixed period. Vague scope is the most common reason a release fails to cover the use you actually made of it.
- Handle the likeness separately. Headshot, video, screen recordings of their product. Attach the actual files or frames you intend to use.
- Handle the trademark separately. Permission to display their logo, with the approved file and any brand guidelines they want followed.
- Strip or substantiate every number. If the quote contains a result, either remove the figure or hold the evidence that supports it, with the method and the period written down. A screenshot of an analytics dashboard with a date range is evidence. A memory is not.
- Get it back in writing and file it with the asset. Email reply is sufficient if it is specific. Store the approval next to the published asset so any team member can find it without asking you.
Build the request into your handover checklist and it stops being a task. This is exactly the kind of step that belongs in an automated sequence rather than a reminder, which is the argument we make in automating client onboarding. Offboarding deserves the same treatment.
Common mistakes, and what to publish when permission is refused
- Trimming a review to its strongest half. This breaks the accordance requirement even though the words are genuine and public.
- Writing the testimonial for the client. Drafting a quote and asking a busy client to rubber stamp it produces approval, but if they never experienced what the quote describes, you have an authorised statement that is still misleading.
- Publishing results without the working. Numbers in quotation marks are still your performance claims.
- Treating a verbal yes as permission. Section 74.02 asks for writing.
- Letting a release go stale. If the person leaves the company, confirm whether the attribution still makes sense. A quote attributed to a role someone no longer holds reads as careless at best.
- Logo walls assembled from the client list. Every mark on that page needs its own permission.
- Incentivised reviews that read as organic. Material connections change how a reader weighs a statement, and the undisclosed version is the version regulators look at hardest.
What to publish instead
Permission gets refused. It is not the end of your social proof. These alternatives carry no authorisation problem because they describe your own work rather than someone else’s words.
| Asset | Why it works | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Anonymised case study | Describes the problem, the mechanism and the build without naming the client | Enough detail to identify them anyway defeats the point |
| Process transparency | Showing how you work is evidence of competence and needs nobody’s sign off | None, this is the safest format you have |
| Public reviews you did not solicit | Already published by the reviewer, so s.74.02 is satisfied | Quote them whole and attribute as written |
| Third party recognition | Awards, directory profiles, published partner badges | Check the badge licence terms |
| Your own published work | Live sites, shipped products, writing that demonstrates expertise | Check the publicity clause before linking a client build |
Placement matters as much as permission. Social proof positioned next to the decision converts better than a testimonial carousel nobody scrolls to, which is the argument in using social proof to increase website conversions. And if you are deciding how much of this to produce and how often, our guidance on publishing cadence applies to case studies too: fewer, defensible, properly produced beats a pile of thin ones.
Frequently asked questions
Can I quote a Google review on my website without asking?
Generally yes under section 74.02, because the reviewer published it themselves. Quote it accurately and in full, and attribute it as it appears. Editing it into something stronger breaks the accordance requirement. Platform terms are a separate question from the statute.
Is a verbal yes on a call enough?
No. Section 74.02’s approval route requires permission given in writing before publication. An email confirming the exact wording is sufficient. A note in your CRM recording that they agreed is not.
Do I need permission to name a client in a case study?
Check your contract first. Many master services agreements make the existence of the engagement confidential. Even without a confidentiality clause, naming the client and showing their logo is a use of their mark, and attaching a named individual’s photograph engages privacy consent. Ask in writing.
Can a client withdraw a testimonial after it is published?
Where the testimonial includes their personal information, the OPC states individuals can withdraw consent at any time, subject to legal or contractual restrictions and reasonable notice. In practice, take it down promptly and keep a record of the request. Fighting it is rarely worth the relationship cost.
Does anyone have to be misled for this to be a problem?
No. Subsection 52(1.1) of the Competition Act states for greater certainty that it is not necessary to prove that any person was deceived or misled, that any member of the public to whom the representation was made was within Canada, or that the representation was made in a place to which the public had access.
Do I have to disclose that a reviewer was given something?
The Competition Bureau pages reviewed for this article set out no standalone material connection rule, but a testimonial that reads as independent when it was paid for can create a false general impression, which is what both section 52 and paragraph 74.01(1)(a) address. Ad Standards’ own code also requires disclosure of material connections. Disclose it.
Can I say “results not typical” and keep the numbers?
It is weak protection. The Bureau advises avoiding fine print disclaimers because “they often fail to change the general impression conveyed by an advertisement”. If the result is not representative, the stronger move is to state what is typical, in the same size type.
The short version
Two routes exist. Either the person published it themselves, or you hold specific written approval obtained before you published, and what you shipped matches it. Everything else is exposure you did not need to take on, for an asset you could have cleared in ten minutes at handover.
The businesses that get this right are not more cautious. They are more systematic. They ask at the moment of maximum goodwill, they ask in writing, they keep the evidence, and they end up with a case study library competitors cannot match because competitors never collected the permissions.
Build the system, not another one off
Wise Media builds the content production systems that turn finished projects into compliant, publishable proof: the release workflow, the case study format, the photography, and the pages the proof actually lives on. If your best work is sitting undocumented because nobody owns the asking, tell us what you are building and we will scope it.



